How Slack Davis Turned A Tragedy Into a Victory for Air Ambulance Safety
On the afternoon of October 19, 2001, a commercial pilot employed by helicopter operator Medical Air Transport, under contract with the Roswell Hospital Corporation, was conducting a landing zone training exercise with the New Mexico State Police in an Aerospatiale AS350B2 air ambulance helicopter. After completing the training, which was held in the parking lot of a state police office, the pilot took three members of the state police for a demonstration flight. During the demonstration flight, the pilot lost control and crashed during a steep banked turn at low altitude. The pilot and one passenger survived with serious injuries; newly commissioned New Mexico State Police officer Damon Talbott and another passenger were killed.
Talbott’s family brought a lawsuit against the Roswell Hospital Corporation, which owned and operated the Eastern New Mexico Medical Center. The Talbotts alleged that the defendant hospital had entered into an agreement with Medical Air Transport to provide air ambulance services for the hospital. The family claimed that the hospital was negligent for failing to exercise reasonable care in the selection and employment of Medical Air Transport, an incompetent and unsafe helicopter contractor, and invoked the legal doctrine codified by the American Law Institute in the Restatement (Second) of Torts Section 411 as its basis for the hospital’s liability to the Talbott family. Even though New Mexico had not expressly adopted Section 411, the trial court agreed with Mr. Slack’s argument that it was applicable in the circumstances of the Talbott lawsuit.
Following a jury trial, in which record damages were awarded to the Talbott family and the hospital was found to be responsible for the crash, the defendant hospital appealed on the basis that the trial court committed an error by not asking the jury to decide whether a contract existed between the hospital and Medical Air Transport. The New Mexico Court of Appeals agreed and reversed the judgment and ordered a new trial.
On the retrial, the Talbott family presented the same evidence as it had in the first trial. However, in the retrial, the existence of a contractual relationship between the hospital and the helicopter operator was submitted to the jury for determination. The jury found that a contractual relationship existed and returned another record jury verdict in favor of the Talbotts and against the hospital. On the resulting appeal, the Court of Appeals affirmed the judgment and expressly adopted Section 411 as New Mexico law. Talbott v. Roswell Hospital Corp., 144 N.M. 753, 192 P.3d 267 (N.M. App.2008). The New Mexico Supreme Court subsequently quashed certiorari, making the Court of Appeals decision final.
With the adoption of Section 411, New Mexico has established a legal duty for hospitals and medical care providers to responsibly screen and reject potentially unsafe or incompetent medical helicopter operators. The Talbott opinion reflects a major step forward for aviation safety in the air ambulance service realm, as well as when companies contract for aviation services for commercial charter purposes.
Slack Davis is proud to have represented the Talbott family and directly contributed to enhancing air ambulance safety standards for New Mexicans and all jurisdictions where hospital and care facility accountability for unsafe air ambulance services is lacking.
Mike Slack represented the firm.
Date of Incident
October 19, 2001
Location of Incident
Roswell, New Mexico
Media Coverage
Eastern New Mexico Medical Center hit with $3.2M fine – The Business Journals
Highway dedicated to two local state policemen – RDR Online
